Dil Maange More tells the story of a young lad Nikhil (Shahid) who is smitten with angelic Neha (Soha). All seems hunky-dory for the easy-going Nikhil until Neha decides to leave her village Samarpur and goes to Mumbai to become an airhostess. Like a true lover, Nikhil follows her to Mumbai.
In Mumbai, Nikhil takes a job at a music store where he falls for another girl, his colleague Sarah (Tulip Joshi). But there is still some space for more love in Nikhil?s heart. Soon he meets his beautiful neighbor Shagun (Ayesha Takia) and is enamored with her too.
Love stories get tangled as Nikhil is torn between three girls. Finally, he decides to straighten up and commit to one girl only. Who will she be?